Dialéctica, ciencia y metafísica en Aristóteles
ISSN: 0066-5215
Année de publication: 2002
Titre de la publication: Los tópicos de Aristóteles (I)
Volumen: 35
Número: 72
Pages: 81-128
Type: Article
D'autres publications dans: Anuario filosófico
Résumé
Showing che importance of art dialectic to science is attempted in this article, at the same time a confusion between them is avoided. To this aim fist, a bríef vision of the characters of science is offered. Then, the essentials characters of dialectic and its divers uses are examined. As a conclusion, it tries to bring to light how the dialectic technique, without giving scientific knowledge at all, is an essential scientific tool.
Références bibliographiques
- I. Gredt, Elementa Philosophiae Aristotelico-thomisticae, Herder, Barcelona, 1961, t. I, 86-88 y 75.
- E. Weil, "The place of Logic in Aristotle's Thought", en J. Barnes/M. Schofield/R. Sorabji (eds.), Articles on Aristotle, n. 1, Duckworth, London, 1975
- Revue de metaphysique et de morale, 1951, 56.
- E. Berti, "La dialectique chez Aristote", en L'attualità della problematica aristotelica, Editrice Antenore, Padua, 1970, 31;
- P. Aubenque, "La notion aristotélicienne d'aporie", en Aristote et les problèmes de méthode, Éditions de l'Institut Supérieur de Philosophie , Louvain-la-Neuve, 1980, 19.
- Aristóteles, Cat., 2, 1 a 25.
- Aristóteles, Cat., 8, 8 b 31;
- An. Post., I, 6, 74 b 32.
- Suzanne Mansion, "Le rôle de l'exposé et de la critique des philosophies antérieures chez Aristote", en Études aristotéliciennes, J. Follon ed., Institut Supérieur de Philosophie, Louvain-la-Neuve, 55-76.
- An. Post., II, 19, 100 b 10
- An. Post, I, 3, 72b 19 y 23.
- Aristóteles, An. Post., I, 9, 76a25.
- An. Post., I, 32, 88a30 ss.
- An. Post., I, 1, 71b17.
- Aristóteles, An. Post., I, 33, 89a 13-16.
- An. Post., I, 2, 72b3.
- W. M. A. Grimaldi, "The Aristotelian Topics", Traditio, 1958 (14), 2-3
- Aristóteles, Met., IV, 7, 1064a4.
- Aristóteles, Met., XIII, 3, 1077b23-30.
- An. Post., I, 30, 87b20;
- II, 12, 96a8,
- Met., IV, 2, 1027a18.
- Aristóteles, Retórica, Q. Racionero (ed.), Gredos, Madrid, 1990.
- An. Post., I, 24, 85 a 13; ver: 30, 87b21.
- An. Post., I, 8, 75b24.
- An. Pr., II, 27,
- Ret., I, 2, 1357a8-b25.
- An. Post., I, 28, 87 a 38
- Aristóteles, Ref. Sof., 11, 172a13.
- Aristóteles, Tóp., I, 1, 100a19;
- Ref. Sof., 34, 183a38.
- Aristóteles, Ref. Sof., 34, 183a37.
- Tóp., I, 3;
- Met., I, 1, 980b26
- V, 12;
- Et. Nic., VI, 1140a 19.
- Aristotele's Posterior Analytics J. Barnes (ed.), Clarendon , Oxford, 1975, 90.
- Aristóteles, An. Pr., I, 2, 24a25;
- An. Pr., I, 30, 46a3;
- Ref. Sof., 9, 170a30.
- Aristóteles, Tóp., I, 10, 104 a 6-12 y 34;
- 11, 104b47, 19 y 31;
- 14, 105 a 37-105b1;
- VIII, 5, 159 a 38-159 b 2, 23-27;
- 9, 160b 17-22.
- Aristóteles, Tóp., I, 14, 105 a 17.
- Aristote, Topiques, J. Brunschwig (ed.), Les Belles Lettres, Paris, 1967.
- Aristóteles, Tóp., I, 11, 104 b 4;
- Ref. Sof., 3, 165 b 14;
- 12, 172 b 29
- De Int., 11, 20b22;
- Tóp., VIII, 2, 158a14.
- Aristóteles, An. Post., I, 11, 77a31.
- Ref. Sof., 1, 165a27.
- Aristóteles, Tóp., VIII, 1, 155b11;
- Ref. Sof., 11, 172a8
- Aristóteles, Tóp., VIII, 14, 163a39.
- Ref. Sof., 2 165 b 1.
- An. Post., I, 12.
- Aristóteles, Et. Nic., VI, 11, 143b11.
- Aristóteles, Ret., I, 1, 4, 1355a15.
- Aristóteles, Tóp., I, 2, 101a29.
- Tóp., VIII, 14, 163b9
- Et. Nic., VI, 7, 1141a17.
- M. Zanatta, "Metodo e statuto epistemologico della Fisica di Aristotele", en Bolletino Filosofico, 1998 (14), 315-345, 323;
- Aristóteles, Tóp., I, 4, 101a36.
- J. M. Gambra, "La petición de principio según Aristóte-les", Philosophica 17, 1994, 13-31.
- Aristóteles, An. Post., II, 19, 100b5-17.
- An. Post., I, 23, 85a1 y 33.
- Aristóteles, Et. Nic., VI, 3, 1139b30.
- Aristóteles, An .Post., I, 9, 76a16.
- "Nulla scientia demonstrat sua propia principia: sed ad Metaphysicam, quae est omnium domina & excellentissima, pertinet probare omnia principia", Dominici Soto, In Porphyrii Isagogen, Aristotelis Categorias, librosque de Demonstratione Absolutissima Commentaria, Venetiis, 1587
- "Metaphysica vero demonstrat quidem principia propria aliarum scientiarum, sed dignitates demonstrare non potest", I. Zabarella Patavini, Opera Logica, Coloniae, 1597
- G. Olms, Hildesheim, 1966.
- I. Pacius a Beriga, In Porphyrii Isagogen et Aristotelis Organum Commentarius Analyticus, Francofurti, 1597, 297 y 280.
- P. Aubenque, "La dialectique chez Aristote", 23;
- E. Berti, "La dialettica in Aristotele", 58-61.
- C. A. Viano, "La dialettica in Aristotele", Studii sulla Dialettica, Taylor, Torino, 1969, 58.
- Aristóteles, Ret., I, 2, 1358a21.
- W. A. de Pater, Les Topiques d'Aristote et la dialectique platonicienne, Études Thomistes, Editions St. Paul, Fribourg, 1965, 117 ss.
- Aristóteles, Et. Nic., I, 7, 1098a25.
- Aristóteles, Et. Nic., I, 3, 1094b13-27;
- Aristóteles, An. Pr., I, 30, 46a24.
- Aristóteles, Met., XI, 5, 1062a2 y 31 ss.
- J. Brunschwig, "Dialectique et ontologie chez Aristote", en Études aristotéliciennes: Metaphysique et Théologie, Vrin, Paris 1980, 226.