Argumentos de dos Tribunales Constitucionales en materia de voto electrónicoAlemania y Austria
ISSN: 1988-5091
Datum der Publikation: 2013
Nummer: 13
Art: Artikel
Andere Publikationen in: Revista general de derecho público comparado
Zusammenfassung
This research studies two sentences of two Constitutional Courts in electronic voting: first, the judgment 3rd March 2009 from the German Federal Constitutional Court and on the other, the judgment 13th December 2011 from the Austrian Constitutional Court. Both pronouncements establish the unconstitutionality and unlawful of electronic voting used in the respective electoral processes but reflect, in their legal basis, on various aspects to consider in order to legally regulate electronic voting in a future.
Bibliographische Referenzen
- BARRAT I ESTEVE J., “Observación electoral y voto electrónico”, Revista Catalana de dret públic, núm. 39, 2009, págs. 277-296;
- BEZEMEK CH., “A Kelsenian model of constitutional adjudication. The Austrian constitutional Court”, ZÖR (2012) 67: 115-128;
- EHRINGFELD A., NABER L., GRECHENIG T., KRIMMER R., TRAXL M., FISCHER G., “Analysis of Recommendation Rec(2004)11 Based on the Experiences of Specific Attacks Against the First Legally Binding Implementation of E-voting in Austria”, Electronic Voting 2010, Casten Hofen, Bregenz, Austria 2010; págs. 225-237;
- FABER R., “The Austrian Constitutional Court- an Overview”, Constitutional Developments, Vol 1, 1/2008, págs. 49-53;
- FERNÁNDEZ RIVEIRA R. M., “¿Es inconstitucional el voto electrónico en Alemania?” en Derecho de Sufragio y participación ciudadana a través de las Nuevas Tecnologías, coords. BARRAT I ESTEVE J. y FERNÁNDEZ RIVEIRA R. Mª, CIVITAS 2011, págs. 157-194;
- KARGER PÍA, “Electronic voting in Germany: Political Elections Online, Utopia or the future?” Electronic Voting and Democracy. A comparative Analysis by KERSTING N. and BALDERSHEIM H.), PALGRAVE MACMILLAN, London 2004, págs.134-149;
- KRIMMER R., EHRINGFELD A., TRAXL M., “The use of E-voting in the Austrian Federation of Students Elections 2009”; Electronic Voting 2010; 4th International Conference, Co-organized by Council of Europe, Gesellschaft für Informatik and E-Voting.CC, July 21st - 24th, 2010, in Castle Hofen, Bregenz, Austria. LNI 167 GI 2010, ISBN 978-3-88579-261-1;
- MARTINEZ DALMAU R., “Aspectos diferenciales del uso del voto electrónico en los procesos electorales y en los órganos colegiados”, Corts. Anuario de Derecho Parlamentario, núm. 25, págs. 229-245;
- PENTZ EVA, “E-voting in the Austrian Student’s Unión elections 2009 was unlawful.”(Austrian Constitutional Court Judgment from 13 December 2011, V 85/11) Constitutional Developments, vol. 6, 1/2012, págs.124-129.
- POIER K., “Postal voting in Austria- First Experience from a Law and Political Science Perspective” Constitutional Developments, vol. 3, 4/2009, págs 255-267;
- PROSSER A., KRIMMER R., and KOFLER R., “Electronic voting in Austria: current state of Public elections” en Electronic Voting and Democracy. A comparative Analysis (edited by KERSTING N. and BALDERSHEIM H.), PALGRAVE MACMILLAN, London 2004, págs. 109-121;
- SCHMIDT A., HEINSON D., LANGER L., OPITZ-TALIDOU Z., RICHTER P., VOLKAMER M., and BUCHMANN J., “Developing a legal framework for Remote electronic voting” en VOTE-ID 2009, LNCS, págs. 92-105;
- SEMBACHER A., “Focus: Right to general, free, equal, secret, personal and direct suffrage”, Constitutional Developments, vol. 6, 1/2012, págs. 122-123;