A Global Campus Beyond the Cold WarPeace and Disarmament Among Spanish Academics during the Debate on Joining and Remaining in NATO (1981-1986)

  1. Giulia Quaggio
Journal:
Culture & History Digital Journal

ISSN: 2253-797X

Year of publication: 2024

Volume: 13

Issue: 1

Type: Article

DOI: 10.3989/CHDJ.2024.293 DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openOpen access editor

More publications in: Culture & History Digital Journal

Abstract

istoriography has recently shown a special interest in assessing the cultural impact of the social engagement of academics during the Cold War through their advocacy of disarmament or human rights. This academic social activism became part of a complex “transnational civil society,” which was to influence international relations. In light of these considerations, this article aims to delve into the distinctive characteristics of the “nuclear culture” and “science diplomacy” of the Spanish academic world between 1981 and 1986. Spain’s experience of the final stage of the Cold War was somewhat unusual. The resurgence of nuclear tension between the two superpowers was mediated by the domestic political transition from a military dictatorship to a parliamentary democracy, but also by the democratisation of foreign policy and the accession of Spain to NATO. To understand how this took place and with what effects, this article will focus on three main points. Firstly, it will set out an analysis of the impact of historian E.P. Thompson’s critical thinking on the Cold War and the European Campaign for Disarmament among Spanish academics. Secondly, it will examine how certain academics, who played an active part in the debate either for or against joining and remaining in NATO, shaped the nuclear culture of the time through the daily press. Finally, it will argue the involvement, or lack thereof, of Spain’s scientific sector in transnational networks for peace and disarmament and how, through civil society itself, the foundations were laid for the first centres aimed at the dissemination and study of peace.

€ View funding

Funding information

Funders

Bibliographic References

  • Aguado i Hernàndez, J. A. (2019) “El pacifismo-antimilitarismo en España desde el siglo XIX hasta la Guerra Civil: los ‘efectos desplazamiento.” Revista de Paz y Conflictos, 12 (1), pp. 85-108.
  • Aguirre, M. and Carbajosa, P. (1993) “Construyendo un espacio teórico: una aproximación bibliográfica a la investigación para la paz en España.” Revista Internacional de Filosofía Política, 2, pp. 99-122.
  • Andrade Blanco, J. (2012) El PCE y el PSOE en (la) Transición. La evolución ideológica de la izquierda durante el proceso de cambio político. México: Siglo XXI.
  • Andrew, C. and Mitrokhin, V. (1999) The Mitrokhin Archive. The KGB in Europe and the West. London: Allen Lane.
  • Arellano García, J. M. (2017) “Los intelectuales en la Transición: Antonio García Santesmases.” Investigación y Letras, 1. Available at: https://revistas.uca.es/index.php/IyL/article/view/3532 [Accessed 28 July 2023].
  • Baehr, P. (2000) “E.P. Thompson and European Nuclear Disarmament (END): A Critical Retrospective.” Online Journal for Peace and Conflict Resolution. Available at: https://ciaotest.cc.columbia.edu/olj/ojpcr/ojpcr_3_1/ojpcr_3_1a.html [Accessed 27 July 2023]
  • Berger, S. and Wicke, C. (2021) “…Dos monstruosas estructuras antagonistas: el activismo pacifista y la filosofía histórica marxista de E.P. Thompson durante la Guerra Fría.” In: S. Berger and C. Cornelissen, eds., Culturas históricas marxistas y movimientos sociales en la Guerra Fría. Zaragoza: Institución Fernando el Católico, pp. 199-224.
  • Bini, E. and Vezzosi, E., eds. (2020) Scienziati e Guerra Fredda. Tra collaborazione e diritti umani. Roma: Viella.
  • Blanco Sío-López, C. (2020) “Transitional margins to re-join the West: Spain’s dual strategy of democratization and Europeanization.” In: L. Crump and S. Erlandsson, eds., Margins for Manoeuvre in Cold War Europe. The Influence of Smaller Powers. New York: Routledge 2020, pp. 205-223.
  • Branciforte, L. (2022) “The women’s peace camp at Comiso, 1983: transnational feminism and the anti-nuclear movement.” Women’s History Review, 31 (2), pp. 316-343.
  • Burke, P. (2016) “European Nuclear Disarmament: Transnational Peace Campaigning in the 1980s.” In: E. Conze, M. Klimke and J. Varon, eds., Nuclear Threats, Nuclear Fear and the Cold War of the 1980s. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 227-250.
  • Capella, J.-R. (2005) La práctica de Manuel Sacristán. Una biografía política. Madrid: Trotta.
  • Centenera Ulecia, J. (2013) La transición exterior española y la larga mano de Moscú. Madrid: Quinquerreme.
  • Clavarino, L. (2021) “Italian Physicists and the Bomb: Edoardo Amaldi’s Network for Arms Control and Peace during the Cold War.” Journal of Contemporary History, 56 (3), pp. 665-692.
  • Colburn, S. (2022) Euromissiles: The Nuclear Weapons That Nearly Destroyed NATO. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
  • Cueva Merino, J. and Louzao Villar, J., eds. (2023) Un 68 católico. Catolicismo e izquierda en los largos años 1960. Madrid: Marcial Pons.
  • De la Torre, J. and Rubio-Varas, M. (2016) “Nuclear Power for a Dictatorship: State and Business involvement in the Spanish Atomic Program, 1950-85.” Journal of Contemporary History, 51 (2), pp. 385-411.
  • Debailly, R. (2015) La critique de la science depuis 1968. Paris: Hermann.
  • Del Val Cid, C. (1996) Opinión pública y opinión publicada: los españoles y el referéndum de la OTAN. Madrid: CIS.
  • Del Val Cid, C. (2023) “Del ‘OTAN no’ al ‘No a la guerra’ de Iraq. Las mil aristas de la opinión pública.” In: F. J. Leira Castiñeira, coord., El pacifismo en España desde 1808 hasta el “No a la Guerra” de Iraq. Madrid: Akal, pp. 553-576.
  • Díaz-Fierros Viqueira, F. (2019) “La crítica de la ciencia en España después del 68.” Arbor, 195 (794), a531.
  • Drago, A. (2012) “Peace Studies and the Peace Movement.” Peace Research, 44-45 (2), pp. 163-191.
  • Echevarría, I. (2012) “La CT: un cambio de paradigma.” In: G. Martínez, ed., CT o la Cultura de la Transición. Critica a 35 años de cultura española. Barcelona: Random House Mondadori, pp. 25-36.
  • Evangelista, M. (1999) Unarmed forces. The transnational movement to end the Cold War. New York: Cornell University Press.
  • Florensa, C. (2021) “A nuclear monument the size of a football field: The diplomatic construction of soil nuclearity in the Palomares accident (Spain, 1966).” Centaurus, 63 (2), pp. 320-338.
  • Freedman, L. (1980) “A criticism of the European nuclear disarmament movement.” Armament and Disarmament Information Unit Report, 2 (4), pp. 1-4.
  • García Camarero, E. (1973) “La responsabilidad social del científico.” Triunfo, 566, pp. 10-11.
  • Garrido Rebolledo, V. (2001) El régimen de no-proliferación nuclear: participación e implicaciones para España. Madrid: UCM.
  • Gassert, P., Geiger, T. and Wentker, H., eds. (2020) The INF Treaty of 1987: A Reappraisal. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
  • Gomáriz Moraga, E. (1987) “El movimiento por la paz en España.” Revista internacional de Sociología, 3, pp. 549-568.
  • Goordeva, I. (2021) “Solidarity in Search of Human Agency: ‘Détente from Below’ and Independent Peace Activists in the Soviet Union.” Labour History Review, 86 (3), pp. 339-368.
  • Grant, M. and Ziemann, B., eds. (2016) Understanding the Imaginary War: Culture, Thought and Nuclear Conflict, 1945-90. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
  • Grasa, R. (1984) “Los movimientos pacifistas en la era nuclear. En pie de paz por la supervivencia.” Mientras Tanto, 18, pp. 21-48.
  • Grasa, R. (1994) “Recordar para sobrevivir: memoria de E.P. Thompson como luchador por la paz, la justicia y el socialismo.” Mientras Tanto, 58, pp. 93-102.
  • Heller, A. and Fehér, F. (1982) “The Antinomies of Peace.” Telos, 21, pp. 5-16.
  • Hogg, J. (2016) British Nuclear Culture: Official and Unofficial Narratives in the Long 20th Century. London: Bloomsbury.
  • Horn, G-R and Kenney, P., eds. (2004) Transnational Moments of Change: Europe, 1945, 1968, 1989. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
  • Isernia, P. (1996) Dove gli angeli non mettono piede. Opinione pubblica e politiche di sicurezza in Italia. Milan: Franco Angeli.
  • Jiménez Torres, D. (2023) La palabra ambigua: Los intelectuales en España (1889-2019). Madrid: Taurus.
  • Kaldor, M. (1981) “The Political Territory of Europe.” END Bulletin, 5, p. 5.
  • Kelly, P. (1984) Fighting for Hope. London: Chatto & Windus.
  • Kennedy, P. (2013) The Spanish Socialist Party and the modernization of Spain. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
  • Kraft, A., Nehring, H. and Sachse, C. eds. (2018) “The Pugwash Conferences and the Global Cold War. Scientists, Transnational networks, and the complexity of nuclear histories.” Journal of Cold War studies, 20 (1), pp. 4-30.
  • Kramer, M., Makko, A. and Ruggenthaler, P., eds. (2021) The Soviet Union and Cold War Neutrality and Nonalignment in Europe. Lanham MD: Lexington Books.
  • Krige, J. (2022) Knowledge Flows in a Global Age. A Transnational Approach. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  • Kuchinskaya, O. (2014) The Politics of Invisibility: Public Knowledge about Radiation Health Effects After Chernobyl. Cambridge: MIT Press.
  • Laucht, C. (2012) Elemental Germans: Klaus Fuchs, Rudolf Peierls and the Making of British Nuclear Culture 1939-59. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
  • Leira Castiñeira, F. J., coord. (2023) El pacifismo en España desde 1808 hasta el «No a la Guerra» de Iraq. Madrid: Akal.
  • Lenz, J. R. (1996) “Pugwash and Russell’s Legacy.” The Bertrand Russell Society Quarterly, 89, pp. 18-24.
  • Maar III, H. R. (2021) Freeze!: The Grassroots Movement to Halt the Arms Race and End the Cold War, Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
  • Magallón Portolés, C. (2009) “El movimiento por la paz en Aragón en los años 80. Un contexto para el nacimiento del SIP.” In: Fundación SIP, ed., 1984-2009. Veinticinco años de trabajo por la paz. Zaragoza: SIP, pp. 17-41.
  • Morin, E. (1983) “El pacifismo europeo: una toma de conciencia inconsciente.” Vardar, 18, noviembre.
  • Muñoz Soro, J. (2016a) “El final de la utopía. Los intelectuales y el referéndum de la OTAN en 1986.” Ayer, 103, pp. 19-49. Available at: https://revistaayer.com/articulo/209 [Accessed 27 July 2023]
  • Muñoz Soro, J. (2016b) “Gli intellettuali spagnoli e la Guerra Fredda durante la dittatura di Franco.” Memoria e Ricerca, 51, pp. 25-44.
  • Nehring, H. (2005) “National Internationalists: British and West German Protests against Nuclear Weapons, the Politics of Transnational Communications and the Social History of the Cold War, 1957-1964.” Contemporary European History, 14 (4), pp. 559-582.
  • Nehring, H. and Pharo, H. (2008) “Introduction: A Peaceful Europe? Negotiating Peace in the Twentieth Century.” Contemporary European History, 17 (3), pp. 277-299.
  • Nehring, H. and Ziemann, B. (2012) “Do all paths lead to Moscow? The NATO dual-track decision and the peace movement – a critique.” Cold War History, 12 (1), pp. 1-24.
  • Norris, R.S., Arkin, W. M. and Burr, W. (1999) “Where They Were.” Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, 55 (6), pp. 26-35.
  • Oliver Olmo, P. (2021) “El movimiento de objeción de conciencia e insumisión en España (1971-2002).” Hispania Nova: Revista de historia contemporánea, 19, pp. 353-388.
  • Ordás García, C. Á. (2022) “The Antimilitarist Campaign against Compulsory Military Service in Spain during the 1970s and 1980s.” Contemporary European History, pp. 1-19.
  • Ortiz Heras, M. and González Madrid, D. A., coords. (2022) La Transición Exterior. La asignatura pendiente de la democratización. Granada: Comares.
  • Owen, D. (1980) Negotiate and Survive. London: Campaign for Labour Victory.
  • Picó, J. and Pecourt, J. (2013) Los intelectuales nunca mueren. Una aproximación sociohistórica (1900-2000). Barcelona: RBA.
  • Prat Carvajal, E. (2007) Moviéndose por la paz. De Pax Christi a las movilizaciones contra la guerra. Barcelona: Hacer.
  • Quaggio, G. (2014) La cultura en Transición. Reconciliación y política cultural en España, 1976-1986, Madrid: Alianza.
  • Quaggio, G. (2023) “En el patio de mi casa, no. Guerra Fría, neutralidad e internacionalismo en el movimiento anti-OTAN y por la paz (1979-1986).” In: F. J. Leira Castiñeira, coord., El pacifismo en España desde 1808 hasta el “No a la Guerra” de Iraq. Madrid: Akal, pp. 473-498.
  • Roberts, G. (2020) “Science, Peace and Internationalism: Frédéric Joliot-Curie, the World Federation of Scientific Workers and the Origins of the Pugwash Movement.” In: A. Kraft and C. Sachse, eds., Science, (Anti-)Communism and Diplomacy. Leiden: Brill, pp. 43-79.
  • Robles, V. (2019) “Más que morir por la patria, hay que vivir por la patria: Carmen Magallón.” Magis, 468. Available at: https://magis.iteso.mx/nota/mas-que-morir-por-la-patria-hay-que-vivir-por-la-patria-carmen-magallon/ [Accessed 29 July 2023].
  • Román Antequera, A. (2023) “Medioambiente y paz: las interconexiones entre el movimiento anti-OTAN y la protesta ecologista en la década de los 1980.” In: G. Quaggio and S. Molina García, eds., Imaginando la Guerra Fría desde los márgenes. La sociedad española y la OTAN. Granada: Comares, pp. 119-136.
  • Ruffini, P-B. (2017) Science and Diplomacy. A New Dimension of International Relations. Cham: Springer.
  • Ruffini, P-B. (2020) “Conceptualizing science diplomacy in the practitioner-driven literature. A critical review.” Humanities and social sciences communications, 7 (1), pp. 1-9.
  • Ruiz Jiménez, J. Á (2005) E.P. Thompson. La conciencia crítica de la Guerra Fría. Democracia, pacifismo y diplomacia ciudadana. Granada: Universidad de Granada.
  • Ruiz Jiménez, J. Á (2006) El Desarme Nuclear Europeo (END). Movimiento social y Diplomacia Civil. Granada: Universidad de Granada.
  • Ruiz Panadero, D. (2022) “Los usos políticos de la paz durante la Guerra Fría. Enrique Líster, la ‘Pax Soviética’ y el Consejo Mundial de la Paz.” Brocar. Cuadernos de Investigación Histórica, 46, pp. 137-166.
  • Sapiro, G. (2009) “Modèles d’intervention politique des intellectuels. Le cas français.” Actes de la recherche en sciences sociales, 176-177, pp. 8-31.
  • Selvage, D. (2021) “From Helsinki to ‘Mars’: Soviet-Bloc Active Measures and the Struggle over Détente in Europe, 1975-1983.” Journal of Cold War Studies, 23 (4), pp. 34-90.
  • Taylor, R. and Fieldhouse, eds. (2013) E.P. Thompson and English radicalism. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
  • Thompson, E. P. (1978) The Poverty of Theory and Other Essays. London: Monthly Review Press.
  • Thompson, E. P. (1985a) The Heavy Dancers. London: Merlin.
  • Thompson, E. P. (1985b) Double Exposure. London: Merlin.
  • Thompson, E. P. and Coates, K., eds. (1981) Human Rights and Disarmament. An Exchange of Letters between E.P. Thompson and Václav Racek. Nottingham: Spokesman.
  • Tompkins, A. S. (2021) “Generating post-modernity: nuclear energy opponents and the future in the 1970s.” European Review of History, 28 (4), pp. 507-530.
  • Voorhees, J. (2002) Dialogue Sustained: The Multilevel Peace Process and the Dartmouth Conference. Washington DC: US Institute of Peace Press.
  • Wirsching, A., Therborn, G., Eley, G., Kaelble, H. and Chassaigne, P. (2011) “The 1970s and 1980s as a Turning Point in European History?” Journal of Modern European History, 9 (1), pp. 8-26.
  • Wittner, L. S. (2003) Toward Nuclear Abolition. A History of the World Nuclear Disarmament Movement, 1971-Present. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.
Data source: Dialnet